I realized that i had nothing describing the project, for those who don't know what it is. I am a Minerva Fellow for Union College, working in conjunction with the Harpswell Foundation, and am in Cambodia from July 2009 through April 2010 to set up a co-operative motorbike repair shop. The goal is to provide jobs for several men from Tramung Chrum, a village that the Harpswell Foundation has worked with in the past. Any income beyond what is required to pay the workers and run the business will go to TC.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

Update^3 and Thoughts on Life Vol. 2

Hi,

So I've been thinking. I tried to break up each section according to topic, but they are sort of interrelated. Also, this ended up being quite long, and has no pictures. Anyway, let's begin.

Section 0: The Current Situation.

As covered in the recent posts, the shop is rough. Morale is low, I'm not really providing a ton of guidance for a variety of reasons, and I'm leaving soon. However, I would like to point out that the shop has a reasonable chance to succeed. I think my previous posts painted an overly dire picture of the situation, and my belief in the shop's potential after I leave has been strengthened. There is enough money left to cover the rent and costs for many more months, probably through the end of the year, which gives the TC guys a fair amount of time to get things in order. One of the TC guys is being trained at a good shop, and will learn an invaluable amount from it about both how to fix motos and how to run a shop. An MIT student is probably coming in the summer, and hopefully she will bring a lot of energy and problem solving ability to the project. In the meantime, to try and deal with the problems the shop is facing, Yousos, Leb Ke, Lee Him, Sai Ha and I are going to meet on the 20th and have a conference of sorts. Hopefully we will collectively come up with some good ways to move the shop forward.

Also, in my previous post I said fairly negative stuff about not caring about the shop, not wanting to deal with it, etc. This is an expression of an emotion, and not an accurate representation of how I am approaching the project. I don't know if this was clear to people, and would like to say that I do care. I have spent 8-ish months trying to make this work, and really do want it to be successful.

The reason I wrote that is that I am stressed out of my damn mind. Trying to sell my dirt bike has been something of a nightmare, and I can't get it out of my head. It's sort of a subtly overwhelming thing. I plan to never be in the position of rushing to sell a vehicle again in my life. I'm also really concerned about having no money when I get back, and the related issue of finding a good job. Also, I'm nervous to have to talk about this experience in front of lots of people, and trying to do something approaching a good job before I leave. And really, Cambodia has worn me down. Living here is not easy.

Section 1: The Blog, Employers, and Conclusions About Me.

There are a few big things I have come to conclusions on. One is that two character traits I consider extremely important, and that I hope to exemplify, are honesty and perseverance. I am confused about my track record on the latter, and am concerned about it. This blog is really honest, maybe even to my detriment, because I have been honest about my failings and frustrations. I'm concerned that potential employers will read my accounts of being really tired of Cambodia, and 'not caring', etc. and think I would be an unworthy employee because I am lacking perseverance or they would just have a generally negative impression of me due to my not-always-positive language.

While thinking about that problem, what I should do about it, and why it has even come about, this is what I realized: generally, when I write on this blog, I have very strong feelings about the situation I am in, and my writing expresses that. So way back when I wrote about my crisis of confidence, I was at a peak of freaking-out-ness, and that blog post is practically frantic. Similarly, when I wrote the recent 'update' post, I was pretty depressed about what was going on, and disappointed in myself for not making this shop totally successful, etc. I think that post may have come across fairly negatively. Really, this blog is a bizarre cross section of me at my most confused and frustrated. It makes me feel better to write about it, but man .... I'm afraid what people who don't know me and haven't wrestled with similar issues must think when they read it. Especially if they are considering whether or not to pay me.

I don't want to edit anything though, because I think it's important to accurately represent my thoughts, however fleeting the exact ones I write may be. And despite being in a somewhat better mood now, the underlying issues are true. The shop is in a tricky spot. Since that post, I have found reasons for the shop being in a weak position that are not my fault, which has made me feel less terrible. For example, the TC guys haven't exactly been taking initiative in the running of the shop. They don't seem to be working their butts off, as I had hoped they would, to make the shop successful.

The human mind is extremely good at rationalizing though, and I can't decide If I am just finding ways to make myself feel better, or if I this is a legitimate point. A counter to the above point is that they are acting the way I am, and being somewhat detached. So I don't know what the truth is.

Summary of this section:
I consider honesty and perseverance important. I know I am honest, but cannot decided how I score on perseverance. This problem is oddly magnified in my blog because I write in it when I am at an emotional peak. I'm concerned that people reading this blog, especially potential employers, will have a negative impression, but I don't want to edit things to put myself in a more positive light.

Section 2: What's Important in Life?

I have been trying to read "Irrational Man" again, which is a summary of existentialism by William Barrett. There are some incredible ideas in there that I would like to quote in the blog. But basically, the point I have gotten out of this second attempt is that man is lost, and we look all over the place for things to make us feel fulfilled. From what I have read, Barrett seems to be making the point that this is because our view of the world has shifted, starting with protestantism. When religion was denuded of its rituals and more 'mythical' attributes, which I think also coincided with science and 'rationality' becoming a more powerful force, Man began walking the road to today's sense of isolation.

This is because rationality is limited, and it cannot explain the world. Barrett uses examples such as Godel's incompleteness theorem's, which use logic to prove that an arithmetic system cannot prove itself to be true. Barrett makes this a broader explanation of logic/rationality being unable to explain itself, let alone everything else.

*Warning - this next paragraph could be totally wrong. I don't have the book with me, and am sort of winging this*

So Barrett says man turned to rationality to explain life, the world, etc, and it hasn't really worked out. Despite our impressive knowledge of math and science, and out ability to make incredible things with it, we have removed ourselves from the realities of life by making life an abstract, rationalized process. This process failed us, and we are lost. We don't really have mystical guiding forces as we did before rationality, and rationality turned out to defeat itself. Barrett uses modern art as an example. His view is that Art represents how people think, basically. So when people viewed the world from a mystical standpoint, and rationality seemed to be working out well, artists portrayed the world as sensible in the form of realism and 'classical' art. That started breaking down though, and people began deconstructing everything. I don't know the whole progression, but we have classical stuff, then weird stuff like cubism that distorts "reality" and makes it 2D, and finally we get to sharks in tanks of formaldehyde, canvases painted one color or seemingly randomly decorated with splashes of color, etc.

We cannot turn back the clock though, and return to a more 'mystical' world view, and he doesn't advocate trying to do that. I haven't gotten to the point where he advocates anything, really, It's still information presentation stage.

What this makes me think about though, Is how to find meaning in life. It basically seems like people find meaning from whatever they spend their time on. This is most commonly a job and a family. I have normally rejected finding meaning from these sources, because they seem like external validation. It would be nice if life meant something innately, and people didn't have to run around searching for things that make them happy, or occupy their time enough.

This is my thought - maybe it's not really very original, but here we go. People have moved beyond the need to survive, and that is, in the end, the meaning of life. Surviving is our most important job, with creating offspring and doing our best to ensure their survival being the next step.

I don't really know how I feel about this though. Survival (from my perspective i.e. lucky enough to be born where I was and into the family I was, obviously there are plenty of people for whom this is not the case) is not really the issue anymore. It is unlikely that I will starve to death or be speared in a war with a neighboring clan/tribe/etc. The issue becomes finding a way to occupy our lives. In the past, the jobs I have had haven't occupied my life enough to fulfill this need. I think I just found the satisfaction gained from doing a good job at something rather empty in the end. I enjoy working, and doing a good job at things, but then I think about what I have done, and it never seems 'important'.

Like back in the day, you and your family were starving. You kill a deer, and feed your family. You survive to maybe kill some more deer. Life makes sense. For the things that don't make sense, you have a bunch of gods.

Designing machine parts, repairing a fence, pumping gas, etc? Pretty abstract in comparison. You do this sort of random stuff, and you earn money, which is a fabricated means to store the ability to buy or own things. God is Dead, and has been dis-proven. Mysteries of Life? Don't think about them, just go buy some Duct Tape. Or watch one of 80000000 TV channels. Or read the news, which I can personally guarantee you will occupy your mind.

Who thinks about this crap anymore? I do, but I'm being broken. I want a job now. I want to design random mechanical doo-dads and earn money so I can spend it on other mechanical doo-dads and some land that really doesn't belong to anyone. I'm not sure I have the willpower to accept a life of survival. This is kind of depressing. I am being absorbed by modern life, into the womb-like embrace of a life of distraction.

Maybe that's the problem, Humans have lost their will to survive, and exist to be placated and fed soft drinks. Wall-E wasn't the future, it's now. Modern Art doesn't make any G damn sense because life doesn't. And nobody seems to care, or they have somehow, mysteriously, found meaning in their life despite it's essential emptiness, and the fact that it is built on fabrications of man, which efficiently distract us from reality. But it's okay, because reality doesn't really make sense any more, and the earth has been deconstructed and abstracted into a parody of life.

Sigh.....

Section 3: Um, I'm going back to the shop now.

I don't know what I'm going to do there, but I'll try and encourage the TC bros to know what they are doing.

Stunningly, I have run out of things to say at the moment.

Take Care.

Ned.

4 comments:

  1. Dear Ned:
    This is a comment on your section 1 above. In my experience, people who are forever and always positive about themselves are either:
    1. Disingenuous 2. Unintelligent 3. Medicated.

    Any employer who does not appreciate honesty, courage, and resilience does so at his/her own peril.

    ReplyDelete
  2. ...and I forgot 4. Demented. above :)

    Who thinks about the meaning of life anymore? I would venture to say many smart people do. It's the "curse" of consciousness. And you are right, sometimes it all seems futile: all that hard work, all the sweat and tears and hopes. But mysteries there are plenty, and goodness is just as universal as evil. Is the universe futile? Perhaps. But there are problems to solve, work to do, people to love. All those activities may be "palliative," but they are not unimportant.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ned, Most people have an existential crisis at some point or another - you are lucky enough to be able to express it really eloquently.  You seem to forget that you are in a foreign country and just beginning to understand everything from the language to the general mindset.     And I don't think it is just about survival - life is also about connecting and caring and just TRYING to do something that matters, and you do those things so well.    Finally, as eager as you are to leave is as eager as many folks here are to see you and hear all about the adventures that didn't make it to the blog.PS Want to hear something REALLY depressing?  This year's Samurai class (with a few exceptions) thought Ghost Dog was "boring"!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi, Ned,

    I agree with most of what you said about the reasons for post-modern difficulty in finding meaning. The issue has been a central one, both personally and in my academic work (it's why I study late-adolescence-and-early-adulthood).
    A few observations and things I've found helpful:

    1) Meaning may be arbitrary, but human nature isn't --- I find we're pretty much unable NOT to find sunsets beautiful, want love and attention, stop to free a trapped animal, etc. That sounds sappy, but I mean that our motives keep motivating us, regardless of our brain's evaluation of them as arbitrary.

    2) Ned, you're in the point in life where things ARE most disconnected and arbitrary -- you've left your family, you don't have new longterm connections to work and other people. For me, having a baby or being faced with a dying family member answered the problem of meaning like being hit over the head with a two by four. The baby looks into your face and no one but you is going to keep it alive. In other words, survival IS an issue, sometimes, in adulthood.

    3) What you write about work feels true to me, for most people -- but I understand it not as an inevitable consequence of moving past survival needs (for the middle and upper classes), but as the alienation of labor in late capitalist society. That's not real comforting -- since you're going to do your life in late capitalist society -- but at least it leads me to think that non-alienated work is POSSIBLE, and if you're really talented and lucky, there's a good chance someone will pay you to do it.

    ReplyDelete